This is SO delicious!!!!! Please keep this stocked. Such a lovely surprise for fall/winter!
Rated 5 out of 5
Robin (verified owner)–
Witch’s Potion tastes great, somewhat like a liquefied spice cake. I’d be happy to drink this all year. Definitely a favorite! 🙂
Rated 5 out of 5
Danica McLean (verified owner)–
This is absolutely one of my favorite flavors. Pumpkin Spice used to be the harbinger of fall for us, but now this has overtaken first place. In Florida, this is as close as we get to traditional autumn.
Rated 5 out of 5
Corinne Sullivan –
This is such a good flavor. Please make it again!
Rated 5 out of 5
Brian (verified owner)–
We had this while visiting at the Salem Inn. We had to find and buy more to have it at home..Soooo flavorful!
Rated 5 out of 5
JHoban (verified owner)–
This is very good! I like the pumpkin spice so decided to give this a try. It reminds me of Chai, but a coffee chai. Very good
Rated 5 out of 5
Harold Herrmann Jr. –
Please bring this flavor back soon
Rated 5 out of 5
Annmarie Ryan (verified owner)–
My daughter in law got hooked on this coffee after I started buying it for the fall both of us enjoy it all year long.wish it was available all year.please bring it back.
Rated 5 out of 5
Dorian (verified owner)–
I found this flavor at a local coffee shop and was thrilled to be able to find it here. Now my 2 bags are gone and just like everywhere else, not a permanent product. PLEASE make this a year long flavor!!
Rated 5 out of 5
Todd Melbourne –
Year round please. K cups would be great too.
Rated 5 out of 5
gibbonsmarlene (verified owner)–
I have been waiting for months for this flavor to come back. I love new England coffee and many of their unique flavors but this is on a whole new level. It is like fall in a cup.
Rated 5 out of 5
Melanie –
I like the witches potion. Where can I buy it? Don’t see it here in your sight
Rated 5 out of 5
Cheryl Korman (verified owner)–
This is my favorite coffee and most requested by visiting family and friends. It would be great to see it year round
Rated 5 out of 5
Dan Fusco (verified owner)–
PLEASE MAKE WITCHES POTION COFFEE YR ROUND!!! PLEASE
Rated 5 out of 5
Kristin (verified owner)–
One of my favorite flavors ever! Please make this year round!!
Rated 5 out of 5
Judy (verified owner)–
Just squeezed one last cup of coffee out of the Witch’s Potion I was able to buy in the fall. I used to look forward to Hickory Farms’ holiday blend which they stopped making years ago and found WB by accident at a local donut shop. Omg, so good. Add me to the list for those who would love to have it year round. I know there are shelf life issues and such so I’ll settle for having it in the fall if it continues to taste as spellbindingly bewitching.
Rated 5 out of 5
Daniel R Fusco (verified owner)–
WOW! Really Really good…Like everyone else, PLEASE make year round availability. Everyone who I have made this for during the fall holidays, says ‘where did you get this, its delicious!’
Rated 5 out of 5
Brian –
Really good!
With all these amazing reviews, why isn’t it year round yet?!?! It’s still the season and I can’t find it anywhere!
Rated 5 out of 5
katelyn –
amazing
Rated 5 out of 5
adam –
Incredible needs to be year round
Rated 5 out of 5
Bethany –
Absolutely love this coffee!! Wish it was available year round. It is my favorite one!!
Rated 5 out of 5
Greg –
Every year, I wait in eager anticipation for my local coffee shop to have this flavor.
I would love to buy grounds to make at home with other brewing methods. Please bring this back for personal sake!
Rated 5 out of 5
Brian –
Literally THE BEST coffee i have ever drank. My absolute fav! This needs to be made yr round!!
Rated 5 out of 5
Paula M (verified owner)–
OMG I am obsessed!! Tried it at my local cafe and now I have to have it for home every day. Best notes of spices.
Rated 5 out of 5
Laura (verified owner)–
A warm, comforting coffee flavor with dirty chai vibes. Every spice seems perfectly balanced, so one doesn’t overwhelm another
Rated 5 out of 5
Brooke Dato (verified owner)–
I am so glad I bought this on a whim… not only is the flavor so very good, the aroma is too! Love waking up to this one. It’s a seasonal flavor, so I’ll be sure to buy more than one bag next year!
Rated 5 out of 5
Erica –
I’m not a huge flavored coffee fan; however, this is the BEST I’ve ever had!! I can get it at work and I just hope/wish you would bring it back to buy online!! I would buy in bulk!! Thank you for this great flavor!!
Rated 3 out of 5
Kevin W –
PLEASE, bring this back.
Rated 5 out of 5
Rosalie Wilberger –
This is great. Will you ever make it again? Love it!
Rated 5 out of 5
Brian L Costa –
DELICIOUS and SOOOOOOO good. I literally consider this to be my favorite coffee flavor of all time. Needs to be made year round!!!
Rated 5 out of 5
smtptk (verified owner)–
Tried this for the first time this year, went back to the site and bought 4 more. I wish I had bought 12 to last the whole year it is so good and I am almost out. Even though this is a fall/Halloween named coffee, I wish you would consider carrying it year round or maybe an approach where you would take pre-orders in larger amounts, because I would do that no question! -(and it looks like others would do the same based on these great reviews!)
Rated 5 out of 5
Cristy Karner (verified owner)–
Witch’s Potion (2020, 2019’s Witch’s Brew) is seriously the favorite flavor in my household! Other times of the year, my husband and I are Cinnamon Sticky Bun drinkers, but when our favorite time of the year rolls around, with all it’s spooky delights, Witch’s Potion rules high! We can’t get enough of this heavenly concoction! We only wish it could be around all year! This year, just like last, we bought a dozen 1 lb bags of whole bean. We seal it up airtight and keep it in a nice dark, cool cupboard. This way we can indulge when the craving is overwhelming. Thank you NEC Bean Artists! You’ve outdone yourselves again! <3
Rated 5 out of 5
Amy Driscoll –
This coffee is so flavorful and good! You definitely should try this flavor you wont be disappointed!
Rated 5 out of 5
Anthony (verified owner)–
I can’t recommend this blend enough, its absolutely spectacular! Its got a cinnamon afterbite with huge cocoa and vanilla notes. You can sense the ginger and its not overpowering. PLEASE, bring this back. I’m so glad I took a chance.
Rated 5 out of 5
Russell Frydryck (verified owner)–
So glad it’s back this year. It’s just a delicious as last year!! My favorite. I got four bags so it will last me until Christmas.
Rated 5 out of 5
Jennifer –
Tried this out today at my favorite bagel shop and I LOVED it! I hope you get it in stock again soon, I’d love to have a bag at home!
Rated 5 out of 5
Russell F –
I love this coffee. Please bring it back in 2020
Rated 5 out of 5
Sally R –
Please bring this back!!! Love this blend!
Rated 5 out of 5
ldsimonjoyce (verified owner)–
This is hands down my favorite flavor from NEC yet! Please make it available year ‘round.
Rated 5 out of 5
Diann –
had this at work and it’s now my favorite coffee!!!! YUM!!
Rated 5 out of 5
Diann –
had this at work and it’s by far my favorite coffee now! YUM!!!
Rated 5 out of 5
Theresa M Mitchell –
I absolutely love this coffee! I’m hoping to find it at the supermarket, if not there is a local donut shop that offers it so hopefully they will sell it by the lb!!
It is the best!
Rated 5 out of 5
Katie Ahlers –
I have had this coffee several times at work and it was delicious! Glad I could order this to have at home.
This is SO delicious!!!!! Please keep this stocked. Such a lovely surprise for fall/winter!
Robin
November 2025
Witch's Potion tastes great, somewhat like a liquefied spice cake. I'd be happy to drink this all year. Definitely a favorite! :)
Danica McLean
October 2025
This is absolutely one of my favorite flavors. Pumpkin Spice used to be the harbinger of fall for us, but now this has overtaken first place. In Florida, this is as close as we get to traditional autumn.
Corinne Sullivan
October 2025
This is such a good flavor. Please make it again!
Brian
October 2025
We had this while visiting at the Salem Inn. We had to find and buy more to have it at home..Soooo flavorful!
JHoban
September 2025
This is very good! I like the pumpkin spice so decided to give this a try. It reminds me of Chai, but a coffee chai. Very good
Harold Herrmann Jr.
May 2025
Please bring this flavor back soon
Annmarie Ryan
May 2025
My daughter in law got hooked on this coffee after I started buying it for the fall both of us enjoy it all year long.wish it was available all year.please bring it back.
Dorian
January 2025
I found this flavor at a local coffee shop and was thrilled to be able to find it here. Now my 2 bags are gone and just like everywhere else, not a permanent product. PLEASE make this a year long flavor!!
Todd Melbourne
October 2024
Year round please. K cups would be great too.
gibbonsmarlene
October 2024
I have been waiting for months for this flavor to come back. I love new England coffee and many of their unique flavors but this is on a whole new level. It is like fall in a cup.
Melanie
August 2024
I like the witches potion. Where can I buy it? Don’t see it here in your sight
Cheryl Korman
July 2024
This is my favorite coffee and most requested by visiting family and friends. It would be great to see it year round
Dan Fusco
February 2024
PLEASE MAKE WITCHES POTION COFFEE YR ROUND!!! PLEASE
Kristin
December 2023
One of my favorite flavors ever! Please make this year round!!
Judy
December 2023
Just squeezed one last cup of coffee out of the Witch's Potion I was able to buy in the fall. I used to look forward to Hickory Farms' holiday blend which they stopped making years ago and found WB by accident at a local donut shop. Omg, so good. Add me to the list for those who would love to have it year round. I know there are shelf life issues and such so I'll settle for having it in the fall if it continues to taste as spellbindingly bewitching.
Apri –
This is SO delicious!!!!! Please keep this stocked. Such a lovely surprise for fall/winter!
Robin (verified owner) –
Witch’s Potion tastes great, somewhat like a liquefied spice cake. I’d be happy to drink this all year. Definitely a favorite! 🙂
Danica McLean (verified owner) –
This is absolutely one of my favorite flavors. Pumpkin Spice used to be the harbinger of fall for us, but now this has overtaken first place. In Florida, this is as close as we get to traditional autumn.
Corinne Sullivan –
This is such a good flavor. Please make it again!
Brian (verified owner) –
We had this while visiting at the Salem Inn. We had to find and buy more to have it at home..Soooo flavorful!
JHoban (verified owner) –
This is very good! I like the pumpkin spice so decided to give this a try. It reminds me of Chai, but a coffee chai. Very good
Harold Herrmann Jr. –
Please bring this flavor back soon
Annmarie Ryan (verified owner) –
My daughter in law got hooked on this coffee after I started buying it for the fall both of us enjoy it all year long.wish it was available all year.please bring it back.
Dorian (verified owner) –
I found this flavor at a local coffee shop and was thrilled to be able to find it here. Now my 2 bags are gone and just like everywhere else, not a permanent product. PLEASE make this a year long flavor!!
Todd Melbourne –
Year round please. K cups would be great too.
gibbonsmarlene (verified owner) –
I have been waiting for months for this flavor to come back. I love new England coffee and many of their unique flavors but this is on a whole new level. It is like fall in a cup.
Melanie –
I like the witches potion. Where can I buy it? Don’t see it here in your sight
Cheryl Korman (verified owner) –
This is my favorite coffee and most requested by visiting family and friends. It would be great to see it year round
Dan Fusco (verified owner) –
PLEASE MAKE WITCHES POTION COFFEE YR ROUND!!! PLEASE
Kristin (verified owner) –
One of my favorite flavors ever! Please make this year round!!
Judy (verified owner) –
Just squeezed one last cup of coffee out of the Witch’s Potion I was able to buy in the fall. I used to look forward to Hickory Farms’ holiday blend which they stopped making years ago and found WB by accident at a local donut shop. Omg, so good. Add me to the list for those who would love to have it year round. I know there are shelf life issues and such so I’ll settle for having it in the fall if it continues to taste as spellbindingly bewitching.
Daniel R Fusco (verified owner) –
WOW! Really Really good…Like everyone else, PLEASE make year round availability. Everyone who I have made this for during the fall holidays, says ‘where did you get this, its delicious!’
Brian –
Really good!
With all these amazing reviews, why isn’t it year round yet?!?! It’s still the season and I can’t find it anywhere!
katelyn –
amazing
adam –
Incredible needs to be year round
Bethany –
Absolutely love this coffee!! Wish it was available year round. It is my favorite one!!
Greg –
Every year, I wait in eager anticipation for my local coffee shop to have this flavor.
I would love to buy grounds to make at home with other brewing methods. Please bring this back for personal sake!
Brian –
Literally THE BEST coffee i have ever drank. My absolute fav! This needs to be made yr round!!
Paula M (verified owner) –
OMG I am obsessed!! Tried it at my local cafe and now I have to have it for home every day. Best notes of spices.
Laura (verified owner) –
A warm, comforting coffee flavor with dirty chai vibes. Every spice seems perfectly balanced, so one doesn’t overwhelm another
Brooke Dato (verified owner) –
I am so glad I bought this on a whim… not only is the flavor so very good, the aroma is too! Love waking up to this one. It’s a seasonal flavor, so I’ll be sure to buy more than one bag next year!
Erica –
I’m not a huge flavored coffee fan; however, this is the BEST I’ve ever had!! I can get it at work and I just hope/wish you would bring it back to buy online!! I would buy in bulk!! Thank you for this great flavor!!
Kevin W –
PLEASE, bring this back.
Rosalie Wilberger –
This is great. Will you ever make it again? Love it!
Brian L Costa –
DELICIOUS and SOOOOOOO good. I literally consider this to be my favorite coffee flavor of all time. Needs to be made year round!!!
smtptk (verified owner) –
Tried this for the first time this year, went back to the site and bought 4 more. I wish I had bought 12 to last the whole year it is so good and I am almost out. Even though this is a fall/Halloween named coffee, I wish you would consider carrying it year round or maybe an approach where you would take pre-orders in larger amounts, because I would do that no question! -(and it looks like others would do the same based on these great reviews!)
Cristy Karner (verified owner) –
Witch’s Potion (2020, 2019’s Witch’s Brew) is seriously the favorite flavor in my household! Other times of the year, my husband and I are Cinnamon Sticky Bun drinkers, but when our favorite time of the year rolls around, with all it’s spooky delights, Witch’s Potion rules high! We can’t get enough of this heavenly concoction! We only wish it could be around all year! This year, just like last, we bought a dozen 1 lb bags of whole bean. We seal it up airtight and keep it in a nice dark, cool cupboard. This way we can indulge when the craving is overwhelming. Thank you NEC Bean Artists! You’ve outdone yourselves again! <3
Amy Driscoll –
This coffee is so flavorful and good! You definitely should try this flavor you wont be disappointed!
Anthony (verified owner) –
I can’t recommend this blend enough, its absolutely spectacular! Its got a cinnamon afterbite with huge cocoa and vanilla notes. You can sense the ginger and its not overpowering. PLEASE, bring this back. I’m so glad I took a chance.
Russell Frydryck (verified owner) –
So glad it’s back this year. It’s just a delicious as last year!! My favorite. I got four bags so it will last me until Christmas.
Jennifer –
Tried this out today at my favorite bagel shop and I LOVED it! I hope you get it in stock again soon, I’d love to have a bag at home!
Russell F –
I love this coffee. Please bring it back in 2020
Sally R –
Please bring this back!!! Love this blend!
ldsimonjoyce (verified owner) –
This is hands down my favorite flavor from NEC yet! Please make it available year ‘round.
Diann –
had this at work and it’s now my favorite coffee!!!! YUM!!
Diann –
had this at work and it’s by far my favorite coffee now! YUM!!!
Theresa M Mitchell –
I absolutely love this coffee! I’m hoping to find it at the supermarket, if not there is a local donut shop that offers it so hopefully they will sell it by the lb!!
It is the best!
Katie Ahlers –
I have had this coffee several times at work and it was delicious! Glad I could order this to have at home.